X

Is “Strong male gives male child” concept Scientific or not?

Is “Strong male gives male child” concept Scientific or not?

A male devotee (Name hidden) asked like this:

“In scripture it is said if male is stronger than female than male child born and vice versa. so here question arises: ancient times Male are more celibate than now that mean there were more male child rather female but how polygamy occurred at that time (one man marry multiple women). 2nd thing, nowadays, both male and female are sexually degraded so how it is said male are sexually weaker than female. Is it scientifically justified or superstition.”

REPLY:

See, if those words are rightly understood, it may seem as authentic and true. If it is doubted, it won’t seem to be authentic.

This will apply to all aspects of life. If we see someone positively, all his actions will seem to be right. If we see him with doubt, all his actions will seem to be wrong.

Your question is based on the words said by Srila Prabhupada in the 4th Canto of Srimad Bhagavatam.

For example, Srila Prabhupada said in SB 4.28.3, that the youth should be trained in brahmacharyain young age.

Why he said so?

He himself has written in his purport for this verse.

Let me explain based on his words.

When a boy is following brahmacharya sincerely without associating with women, his energy is saved, not wasted.

Since he follows purity, he will have genuine wish to marry earlier.

Because of his pure life during his brahmacharya period, he would not have wasted his energy.

So, if he marries in the right age, he will have more sexual strength and potency. And, he will beget healthy children.

Srila Prabhupada says that male children will be more if the males follow purity and folllow sex only with the wife and only for procreation.

If the males are sexually strong, he will get more male children as said by Srila Prabhupada in his purport.

If the females follow more purity than males, there will be more stronger women in the society and hence the number of female children will be more.

In case males involve in some prohibitted, violative, acts, they would have lost their energies. So, their potency and strength may not be upto the mark.

So, these weaker males may not have strength to produce male children more.

At the same time, the females are following more purity than males and hence they have good sexual strength.

Briefly speaking, males are wasting their energy more and females are preserving more. So, the females are stronger than males in producing children.

So, there are more female children.

This is what Srila Prabhupada has said in this verse of Bhagavatam.

Is that concept wrong?

It has a chance for being true also.

Srila Prabhupada says that strong males give male child and strong wife gives female child.

Until it is proven that it is not possible, it is to be taken as correct.

These things can’t be proved because these are private matters happening privately.

So, there are more chances for them to be true.

Now your question:

(1) Ancient times Male are more celibate than now. That means there were more male child rather female but how polygamy occurred at that time (one man marry multiple women).

REPLY:

Yes, once upon a time, the males were more than females.

Now the males are less than females throughout the world.

But, the males being more than females existed only among the common people. But, among kshatriyas, the females were more than males because males had to die in wars during war times.

So, this Polygamy for status existed only among kshatriyas.

Though polygamy was not prohibitted in the scriptures for all, there must be valid reasons.

For example, the male should marry another woman with the consent of first wife only if he did not get a child or a male child thru the first wife for 10 years.

Polygamy was allowed only for getting a child or male child.

Polygamy was not allowed for having more pleasures for common man.

Such free polygamy was allwoed only for kshatriyas/ kings.

Common man should have valid reason like death of spouse, getting no children or male children for about 10 years, etc.

So, the polygamy for common man was regulated one, but for kshatriyas, they were allowed to follow polygamy even as a status. They had a practice of bringing the women as slaves from the country conquerred by them.

But, Ha Ha, Common man can’t do so by fighting with a neighbour and winning.

(2) 2nd thing, nowadays, both male and female are sexually degraded so how it is said male are sexually weaker than female. Is it scientifically justified or superstition?

REPLY:

Though violations happen among both males and females, other forms of sex are less among females even now.

So, though they violate once or twice, they recover fast and set them right honestly.

In otherwords, habitual violators are comparatively less in females than males.

But we cabn’t deny that violations happen among both the males and females.

It is more among males.

And, in sexual exchanges, generally, the males are givers and females are receivers.

So, loss of energy will be more in males than females.

So, though a male and female violate, the loss of energy will be more for a male than a female.

So, there are more female children now as per the purport of Srila Prabhupada for Srimad Bhagavatam 4.28.3.

Hope you are clear now with these simple explanations whether the “Strong male gives male child” concept Scientific or not.

RELATED POSTS